2007

Four Continents Championships

Men's Event

By Lynn Rutherford

All photos Copyright 2007 by George S. Rossano

 
Final Standings
Place Skater Country SP FS
1 Evan Lysacek USA 4 1
2 Jeffrey Buttle CAN 1 2
3 Jeremy Abbott USA 2 4
4 Ryan Bradley USA 3 5
5 Christopher Mabee CAN 8 3
6 Jialiang Wu CHN 6 7
7 Noriyuki Kanzaki JPN 7 8
8 Kenesuke Nakaniwa JPN 9 6
9 Emanuel Sandhu CAN 5 10
10 Ming Xu CHN 10 9
11 Zhixue Yang CHN 12 11
12 Yasuharu Nanri JPN 11 12
13 Sean Carlow AUS 13 13
14 Joel Watson NZL 14 14
15 Tristan Thode NZL 15 15
16 Nicholas Fernandez AUS 16 18
17 Luis Hernandez MEX 19 16
18 Mathieu Wilson NZL 21 17
19 Justin Pietersen RSA 18 20
21 Dean Timmins AUS 20 19
21 Adrian Avalrado MEX 17 21

 

Short Program

 
Starting Order - Short Program
  1. Joel Watson

  2. Adrian Avalrado

  3. Mathieu Wilson

  4. Ryan Bradley

  5. Nicholas Fernandez

  6. Zhixue Yang

  7. Ming Xu

  8. Dean Timmins

  9. Noriyuki Kanzaki

  10. Jeremy Abbott

  11. Kenesuke Nakaniwa

  12. Luis Hernandez

  13. Yasuharu Nanri

  14. Emanuel Sandhu

  15. Justin Pietersen

  16. Sean Carlow

  17. Jialiang Wu

  18. Tristan Thode

  19. Evan Lysacek

  20. Jeffrey Buttle

  21. Christopher Mabee

 

Short Program Placements
Place Skater Country
1 Jeffrey Buttle CAN
2 Jeremy Abbott USA
3 Ryan Bradley USA
4 Evan Lysacek USA
5 Emanuel Sandhu CAN
6 Jialiang Wu CHN
7 Noriyuki Kanzaki JPN
8 Christopher Mabee CAN
9 Kenesuke Nakaniwa JPN
10 Ming Xu CHN
11 Yasuharu Nanri JPN
12 Zhixue Yang CHN
13 Sean Carlow AUS
14 Joel Watson NZL
15 Tristan Thode NZL
16 Nicholas Fernandez AUS
17 Adrian Avalrado MEX
18 Justin Pietersen RSA
19 Luis Hernandez MEX
20 Dean Timmins AUS
21 Mathieu Wilson NZL

Jeffrey Buttle

Jeremy Abbott

Ryan Bradley


At Four Continents, "4" is the New "6" for Buttle

Two weeks ago at the State Farm U.S. Championships in Spokane, Evan Lysacek proved he could skate a clean short program.

"It was a huge weight off my shoulders," said the 21 year-old skater, who had faltered in the short at the 2006 Olympics and other important competitions.

Tonight, a few pounds of baggage must have come back.

Skating fourth in the final warm-up group at Colorado Springs’ World Skating Arena, a sluggish Lysacek reduced a planned triple Lutz-triple toe loop combination to a triple-double and then doubled a flip in his program to "The Feeling Begins." Though the remaining elements were more than respectable, the routine did not pack a fraction of the excitement it had in Spokane.

"This was a really strange night, with so few people in the audience," the newly crowned U.S. champion, who won Four Continents in 2005, said. "I’m the kind of person that usually feeds off energy, and there was no energy. It’s been a crazy week; I’m still riding the high of Nationals.

"I wanted to show up (at Four Continents); I wanted to come, because it’s in the U.S. But it was tough to be perfect with all that was going on."

In an evening with few clean performances, Lysacek’s 67.04 points (33 TES + 34.04 PCS) left him in fourth place, more than ten points off the lead.

If Lysacek wants to win his second Four Continents title, he will have to catch three-time Canadian champ Jeffrey Buttle, who earned the rare distinction of gaining "Level 4" for each of his program’s five non-jumping elements.

Performing to Astor Piazzolla "Adios Nonino," with masterful choreography by David Wilson, the Olympic bronze medalist closed his program with expressive and varied step sequences and a crisp, well-centered combination spin –impressive enough to make observers forget about his earlier near-fall (both hands down) on a triple Axel. He was rewarded with 77.72 points (41.58 TES + 36.14 PCS), a new ISU personal best.

"For my first international this season, a clean program would have been awesome today, but it’s an improvement over Canadians and I’ll take it," Buttle said. "All of the extra effort I put into my spins and steps paid off. At Canadians I had left out a couple of things so it was cool to go out and do them."

It was a triumphant return for Buttle, who missed the Grand Prix season with a back injury, stayed off the ice for three months and only began training again in November.

"No specific element caused my injury. It was due to repetitive stress, caused by impact and torque. My body was telling me it needed more than two weeks off," said Buttle, who is the only active skater continuously able to increase his point totals despite major jumping mistakes.

Hometown skater Jeremy Abbott, who placed fourth at the U.S. Championships, thrilled the sparse crowd with a clean program to "Dead Already" marked by crisp positions and angular movements. Abbot, who is coached in Colorado Springs by Tom Zakrajsek, landed a triple Lutz-triple toe loop; a triple Axel; and a triple loop, and all three of his spins were graded Level 4.

It was an astounding improvement over his disastrous short in Spokane, and put him in second place with 74.34 points (41.91 TES + 32.43 PCS).

"The difference (between here and nationals) was that I was much better prepared mentally," Abbott, 21, said. "It was my first senior nationals, the first time I had to deal with cameras. I was distracted mentally. I knew what to expect here."

Abbott’s training partner, surprise U.S. silver medalist Ryan Bradley, delighted the crowd with his short to "Happy Birthday Polka." The charismatic 23 year-old, who is also coached by Zakrajsek, reduced an intended triple flip- triple toe loop combination to a triple-double, but was otherwise solid. He gained Level 4 for all three of his spin elements, a vast improvement over prior years.

Bradley admitted it was a bit difficult to get motivated for this event.

"It was kind of hard to get into competition mode," he explained. "I live just down the street, so my coaches worked with me to help me adapt."

About his unusual short program -- which has him dressed in a bright blue pants, a canary yellow top, orange suspenders and a painted-on polka dot tie – Bradley said, "I feel I was criticized in the past for being a clown on the ice. People would say, ‘He’s a clown, he doesn’t focus on his skating skills, he just likes to make people laugh.’ I decided let’s go with it. They’re saying I’m a clown, let’s do a clown program."

Bradley picked up 68.83 points (37.19 TES + 31.64 PCS) and sits in third place.

Enigmatic Canadian Emanuel Sandhu added an unfortunate chapter to his biography when he ran into lace trouble while performing his short program to a Latin medley.

After landing a quadruple toe loop-double toe combination – albeit with a bit of a running edge between the jumps – the top hook on his right boot began to loosen, and he popped an intended triple Axel into a single. After completing a flying sit spin, Sandhu began his circular step sequence, only to have the lace fly loose.

"I felt like I had on ballet slippers," Sandhu said. "I tried to do my Axel but unfortunately the boot could not support the technique. When it came off completely during the steps, I knew I had to stop."

The three-time Canadian champion skated over to the referee, detailed the problem and was granted two minutes to fix it. He did, and executed the remaining elements (including a triple Lutz, change foot sit spin, straight-line sequence and combination spin) although the steam had gone out of the program.

"I’m not used to stopping. It’s a difficult thing. It was a mental battle and I stuck with it. The rest of the program was good," Sandhu said. He placed fifth with 64.98 points (32.15 TES + 32.83 PCS).

Jialiang Wu of China was the top finisher among the three entrants from his country, placing sixth with 63.52 points. The two-time national bronze medalist had one of the cleaner programs of the night, landing a strong triple Axel and triple flip-triple toe combination.

The top Japanese finisher was stylish Noriyuka Kanzaki, competing in his first major international, who interpreted Ravel’s "Bolero" with an unusual combination of restraint and flair. He opened his program with the finest triple Axel of the night, followed by a triple toe loop-triple toe loop combination, but fell on a triple Lutz. He sits seventh with 62.34 points.

"I think I was leaning forward on the Lutz," Kanzaki said. "It was a pity, but the last part of my (straight-line) step sequence was good. I’m glad because it was overall a good performance."

Canadian bronze medalist Christopher Mabee had a disappointing outing to "Blue Deluxe," falling on his triple flip and putting a hand down in the middle of his triple Lutz-double toe loop combination.

"I was very well trained coming in to this competition and practicing well here all week," Mabee said. "After I landed the triple Axel I started to become more cautious and slowed it down a bit. I’ll go for it in the long."

 

Free Skating

 
Starting Order - Free Skating
  1. Justin Pietersen

  2. Adrian Avalrado

  3. Dean Timmins

  4. Mathieu Wilson

  5. Luis Hernandez

  6. Nicholas Fernandez

  7. Sean Carlow

  8. Tristan Thode

  9. Joel Watson

  10. Zhixue Yang

  11. Yasuharu Nanri

  12. Christopher Mabee

  13. Kenesuke Nakaniwa

  14. Ming Xu

  15. Noriyuki Kanzaki

  16. Jeremy Abbott

  17. Jeffrey Buttle

  18. Emanuel Sandhu

  19. Evan Lysacek

  20. Jialiang Wu

  21. Ryan Bradley

 

Free Skating Placements
Place Skater Country
1 Evan Lysacek USA
2 Jeffrey Buttle CAN
3 Christopher Mabee CAN
4 Jeremy Abbott USA
5 Ryan Bradley USA
6 Kenesuke Nakaniwa JPN
7 Jialiang Wu CHN
8 Noriyuki Kanzaki JPN
9 Ming Xu CHN
10 Emanuel Sandhu CAN
11 Zhixue Yang CHN
12 Yasuharu Nanri JPN
13 Sean Carlow AUS
14 Joel Watson NZL
15 Tristan Thode NZL
16 Luis Hernandez MEX
17 Mathieu Wilson NZL
18 Nicholas Fernandez AUS
19 Dean Timmins AUS
20 Justin Pietersen RSA
21 Adrian Avalrado MEX

Evan Lysacek

Jeffrey Buttle

Jeremy Abbott

 


Lysacek Outduels Buttle

Bizet’s bad girl has been very, very good to Evan Lysacek.

After winning Cup of China, the 21 year-old skater discarded his first impulse to get a new free program, sticking with "Carmen," the old standby he debuted at the 2006 NHK Trophy and performed during his fourth-place finish at the Turin Olympics. An electric performance to the classic, including Lysacek’s first-ever quad toe-triple toe combination, rewarded him with his first U.S. title in Spokane two weeks ago.

Here, Lysacek’s powerful performance outgunned the more cerebral Jeff Buttle as the American made up a 10.68-point deficit after the short program to win his second Four Continents title.

"My goal was to land a quad toe here, and get it to be just like any other jump in my program," Lysacek said. "I don’t want it to seem like a new thing any more."

Lysacek opened with a clean (+.43 GOE) quad combination, but put a hand down on his second jump, a triple Axel. He recovered with a solid triple loop (+.71 GOE) and triple Salchow (+.14 GOE).

From that point on, the skater was home free, landing a strong triple Axel-triple toe combination (+1 GOE) and triple flip-double toe-double loop (+.43) after the halfway mark. His circular steps were freer and more open than at the U.S. Championships, but he seemed a bit cautious during his straight-line steps.

"Tonight was a big step down from Nationals," Lysacek said. "You can’t compare the two. I’m glad I was able to come and fight through that performance."

Lysacek, who earned an ISU personal best 159.23 points for 226.27 total, now turns his attention to the upcoming World Championships in Tokyo, where he will face off against jumping powerhouse Brian Joubert of France.

"I’m going to sit down with my coach, Frank Carroll, when we go home," Lysacek said. "Right now my program is so technically grueling it will rival anyone’s. It’s all about improving my artistry."

Performing to music from the soundtrack of "Ararat," a Canadian-made film about Armenian genocide, Buttle’s spins, transitions and footwork were innovative and superb, particularly an unusual change-foot upright spin (Level 4, +.43), but his jumps let him down.

He doubled his first intended triple Axel, and later popped another attempt into a single. Since the top two men were judged almost even on Program Components, these jumping mistakes -- plus the lack of a quad – cost Buttle the title. He placed second in the free skate with 146.24 points (71.94 TES + 74.30 PCS) and second overall with 223.96 total.

"Obviously it was not the skate I wanted, jump-wise," Buttle said. "I didn’t commit to the triple Axel. It felt comfortable in practice but I need to go home, work harder and make up for lost time." (This was Buttle’s first international competition of the season. He missed his fall Grand Prix events with an injured back.)

Canadian silver medalist Christopher Mabee recovered from a disastrous short program to place third in the free with a solid, crowd-pleasing performance to a Big Band selection. The 21 year-old from Ontario, who is coached by Lee Barkell and Doug Leigh, opened poorly with a popped triple loop. He put that mistake aside to land an excellent triple Axel-triple toe loop combination (+1.57 GOE), one of the few he has done in competition, and followed up with a triple Lutz-double toe (0 GOE). He did not "hold" a running edge on his second triple Axel (-.43 GOE) but covered it well by moving immediately into some transition steps.

Mabee’s entertaining straight-line steps (Level 3) with intricate stops and turns were done to a drum beat, and he improvised by replacing the planned triple Salchow following the steps with a triple loop (-.57 GOE).

The Canadian earned a personal best 129.83 points for third place in the free skate. Overall, he placed fifth with 188.41.

"My practices here were kind of all over the place and I really couldn’t find my groove but I found it out there," Mabee said. "My coach (Barkell) just kept telling me to rely on my training and know that when I came in here I was skating amazing."

Jeremy Abbott, the stylish young skater who placed fourth in Spokane, sat in second here after a superb short. He was unable to recapture the intensity and excitement he showed during his free skate at U.S. Nationals, but had a more-than-respectable outing to a classical medley including Mozart’s Symphony No. 25.

Abbott tripled an opening quad toe attempt, and then stumbled on the landing of his triple Axel before executing a triple toe (-1.29 GOE). Two unfortunate misses – a popped triple Axel and popped triple Lutz – disrupted the program. Abbott recovered with a strong straight-line footwork sequence (Level 3, +.36 GOE) followed by a triple loop. His excellent circular steps (Level 3. +.50 GOE) had good energy, and he closed with a well-centered Level 4 sit spin (+.57 GOE).

"At Nationals I felt a lot looser and freer when I skated," Abbott, who trains in Colorado Springs with Tom Zakrajsek, said. "It’s my first major senior international, so it’s a respectable showing."

Charismatic Ryan Bradley was likewise unable to equal his Spokane free skate. The 23 year-old, who also trains with Zakrajsek, "muscled" through many of the jumps in his program to a Latin medley. After opening with a triple Axel-triple toe combination, he fell on a triple Lutz. Later in the program, he doubled both a triple Axel and triple flip.

While the hometown crowd yelled its support, Bradley tired a bit during his circular steps, although he recovered with a fine closing combination spin. He earned 127.46 points (65.26 TES + 63.20 PCS) for fifth place in the free skate, and placed fourth overall with 196.29 points.

Kensuke Nakaniwa, who placed fifth at the most recent Japanese Nationals, had a strong free skate to the lyrical "Slow Dance in the Big City" that was perhaps a bit under appreciated by the judges. He opened with a clean quad toe (+.14), one of only two in the event, and followed up with six triples (including two Lutzes), with two done in combination.

Not just a jumper, the 25 year-old from Fukuoka showed excellent edges in his Level 3 circular footwork and a difficult spread eagle entrance into a triple flip. His weak closing combination spin likely hurt his component score, as did his comparative lack of a resume.

Nakiniwa earned 121.69 points (66.47 TES + 55.22 CPS) for sixth place in the free skate, and was eighth overall with 177.03 points.

Chinese bronze medalist Jialiang Wu has the highest triple Axel I have ever seen, with incredibly fast rotations in the air. Unfortunately, he stumbled out of the triple toe portion of his opening triple Axel-triple toe combo, and later ran out of gas, doubling an intended triple Salchow and moving extremely slow during his straight-line steps.

Wu earned 121.17 points, a new personal best, and placed seventh in the free and sixth overall.

Noriyuki Kanzaki of Japan, who placed fourth at Japanese Nationals, performed his free skate to "Phantom of the Opera," the same music used by his countryman Daisuke Takahashi. Overall, it was a good performance, but he seemed to be fighting the altitude and fatigue a bit. He scored 119.24 points in the free and 181.58 total for seventh place.

Kanzaki has announced that this is his final competition, as he is returning to Kyoto University full-time to pursue a master’s degree.

Ming Xu, second at the 2007 Chinese Nationals, showed good jumps and style, but like Wu, his "meat and potatoes" choreography and simple, Level 1 spins hurt his score. He placed ninth in the free and 10th overall.

The less said about Emanuel Sandhu’s free skate, the better. Rarely has the maddeningly inconsistent Canadian been worse, although he still has one competition (Worlds) to go this year. He placed tenth in the free and ninth overall.

Zhixue Yang of China fell on his opening quad toe attempt and placed 11th in the free skate and 11th overall.

Japanese bronze medalist Yasuharu Nanri had a disastrous performance to "Carmen," falling on his opening triple Axel, seemingly injuring himself, and reducing many of his remaining elements. He dropped to 12th place.

2007 Four Continents Men's Medalists

 

Return to title page