2011 Grand Prix FinalLadies Event |
|
Carolina Kostner |
Kostner Takes Gold. Tuktamisheva Recovers in Free Skate but not Enough to Medal. by Alexandra Stevenson 1.Overall 187.48 Carolina Kostner, 1.FS 121.05 (55.83+65.22). The 24-year-old Italian, who was third in the world championships last April, won both SP & FS with a considerable margin, despite no longer presenting a triple Lutz. Her FS technical score, however, was only fourth best of the five competitors, though her components were well ahead of her adversaries. Skating in a grey-blue catsuit to music from the second and third movements of Mozart’s Piano Concerto No.23 in A Major, she opened with a +0.70 triple loop. But she touched her hand down on the landing of the following triple flip which had -0.70 removed from the base value and she singled her first attempt at a double Axel. When the bonus marks clicked in she executed a +1.10 double Axel to triple toe, a strained base value triple toe to double toe, a -0.40 triple Salchow with a jacknifed landing and a +0.70 triple Salchow to double toe. Two of her spins, a +0.43 flying camel, and the concluding element, a +0.64 a change foot combination, were Level 4. But the flying change foot combo was only +0.24 Level 2. Her straight line steps were a good +1.07 Level 3. She said, "I wish I would have skated better. My Short Program went so well. It was a fight today. At first I was a little upset at the mistakes I made on the flip until the single Axel. Then I thought, "Now, I have nothing to lose. It’s all or nothing. I am glad that I didn’t let myself go. It was a good exercise for me to be in the lead. Sometimes I was in behind in the Short and it is different to defend rather than attack. I think I am still a little bit nervous because I was really nervous going into the competition. It was the first time for me (being in the lead after the SP) to defend something that felt so important. I am so happy that I did not have major mistakes but I have the feeling that I could have done better. " I think the most important thing, now, is Christmas at home with my family because I haven’t been home for so long. So, just to relax and have some calm days, is just what I need. Honestly, when I came into this competition I felt not as good as everyone else because I don’t have the triple Lutz in my program. I still have some technical things to work on and I feel that I want to stabalize what I can do before I go into a program with a full head and lose myself. I look forward to the moment I can add it again." Her FS score was her Season’s Best. This was her first Grand Prix Final gold. However, she earned silver in last year’s Final and bronze in the previous two years. She also earned silver in the Junior Grand Prix back in 2003.2.Overall 179.76 Akiko Suzuki, 3.FS 118.46 (56.53+61.93) The 26-year old from Toyohashi in Aichi Prefecture trains in Nagoya but her choreography was created by Anjelika Krylova and Pasquale Camerlengo at the Detroit SC. Dressed in a fushia dress, she performed to music from Die Fledermaus. There is so much talent in Japan, that, although she was 8th in the Olympics and 11th in the following Worlds, she did not make the world team this past season. She began the routine a little tentatively with a -0.60 triple Lutz in which she was leaning in the air and so the landing was not perfect. But that was followed by a double Axel to triple toe loop and a triple loop which both earned +0.80 GoE. Then came two Level 4 spins (+0.71 and +0.43), and her choroegraphed spirals. However, at the halfway mark, she did a -1.10 triple loop with a hop-hop on the landing and she stepped out of a triple Lutz which had -1.40 removed from its base value. Her last two jumping passes were good, a +0.50 triple flip and a +0.30 triple Salchow. She concluded with two Level 3 moves, straight line steps, which earned an extra 1.07, and a +0.50 flying change foot combo spin. Although she was third in the FS, she held on to second place by a margin of 3.34. This was her second Grand Prix Final medal. In the Olympic season she won the bronze, but was fourth last year. Way back in 2002, she won bronze in the Junior Grand Prix Final. She said, "The result (silver) is very good and I am happy with it. But the performance itself was disappointing. During today’s practice time, I felt good and was hoping to continue like that. But during the six-minute warm up, my body was still. I was trying to be positive, but I did not succeed. My overall feeling is I am not totally happy. This is the best place ever for me in the Grand Prix Final (she won bronze in December 2009 and was fourth last season), and I am happy, but the program could have been better. I did not skate my best, and I am not happy about the content tonight."3.Overall 176.42 Alena Leonova, 4. FS 115.96 (57.95+59.01 -1). The Russian from St. Petersburg, who turned 21 on November 23, was fourth in the world championships last April and ninth in the Olympics but she has never been national champion. She came into this event as the sixth and last qualifier, with a third place in the NHK Grand Prix in Sapporo and a second in her home country Grand Prix. So this result was better than expected. Although she has competed in Grand Prix events since 2008, this was only her second time to qualify for the Final. Last season, when the Final was in Beijing, she finished sixth of the six competitors. Leonova opened her routine set to Samuel Barber’s Adagio for Strings and Clint Mansell’s Requiem for a Tower, with a very good combination of two triple toe loops, which earned +2s from eight of the nine judges (with the dissenter punching in only 0). But then she doubled her loop. "I was rushing going into the loop and decided to do a clean double instead of risking a fall. It was an unfortunate error as I did an excellent triple loop in the warm up and in practices." Then she fell on her triple Lutz. "I am very disappointed about the Lutz as after the Rostelecom Cup my coach (Alia Piatova) changed the approach going into the jump so I would feel more comfortable in order to have the correct (takeoff) edge. I do not know whether the (Technical Panel) credited me with the correct edge today (they did) so I will have to review the protocols. If they did, I will continue working on this approach. After the fall, I just concentrated on the rest of the program." She got back in stride with a +0.43 Level 3 change foot camel, a +0.70 triple flip to double toe set for when the bonus marks click in, the choreographed spirals and a base value triple Salchow to double toe to double loop. But her second triple flip got -0.40 removed from the base value and a double Axel "only" received +0.07 extra. She concluded with three good moves, a +0.36 Level 4 flying sit spin, +0.93 straight line steps for which one judge gave the maximum +3GoE, and a Level 4 +0.57 change foot combination spin. "I was very excited about the crowd cheering me on during the straight line step sequence in practice and I expected to have even louder cheering during the Free Skate, which definitely helped my performance. I am very pleased with myself for not getting tired after competing in three Grand Prix events this fall (a new situation this season in which the world’s top skaters can choose to do an extra event with only the best two finishes counting towards qualifying for the Final). Leonova was fourth in Skate Canada. She said, "I am very happy with my first medal at the Grand Prix Final. (She made the Final once before – placing 6th in the Olympic season.) I don’t have many emotions right now because I can’t quite grasp it. I am very happy to place third. I try not to pay attention to the pressure. I just want to skate my best. My goal is always to skate well and not to think about placement and scores."4.Overall 174.51 Elizaveta Tuktamisheva, 2.FS 119.52 (63.86+55.68), who gave dazzling performances to win Skate Canada and the French Grand Prix events but would not turn 15 until December 17 and so is still too young for the World Senior championship in Nice, came into this event as the top qualifier. But her less than stellar SP had her lying 5.31 points behind the fourth placed Alissa Czisny.However, her energetic, Latin-flavored Free was judged second best to Kostner, just 1.53 points behind the gold medalist. Tuktamisheva’s Elements score (63.86) was the highest by 5.91. (Her Russian teammate, Leonova, earned the second highest elements score of 57.95.) However, the judges gave Tuktamisheva the lowest components marks, 55.66 almost ten points (9.56) behind the Italian. Tuktamisheva is from Glazov, a stop on the Trans Siberian Railroad, which is home to Russia’s top uranium processor and is most famous for being the home town of Anton Chekhov’s actress wife. However, after an interim two-year period when she traveled a 24-hour rail journey twice a month to get instruction from Alexei Mishin, she now lives in that city. She began her routine with a superb triple Lutz to triple toe, which had beautifully light landings on both jumps and which earned six +2 and three +1s from the judges. But she stepped out of her second triple Lutz, which came immediately following the first, and it was saddled with six -2s and three -1s. A triple flip was rewarded with eight +1s and one +2. She almost came to a stop on the landing of the second jump in her fourth element, a double Axel to triple toe. Her circular steps were Level 2 with +0.29 and her triple Loop, set to take advantage of the bonus marks clicking in at the half way stage, earned +0.90. The rest of the program was faultless. Her GoE for the choreographed spirals, which only receive Level 1 worth two points, got an extra +0.50 from the judges. Two Level 4 spins received +0.50 for the flying sit and +0.79 for the change foot combination. Her triple Salchow to double toe to double loop got an extra +0.20. Her second double Axel received +0.57 and her final move, a Level 3 camel spin was rewarded with +0.64. She said, "I realized after yesterday that I have nothing to lose and I have to just skate well for myself. I changed my costume from black and red to green to help feel the Latin music. My best element was the triple Lutz-triple toe combination and the worst the double Axel to triple toe. I learned from this event that there is nothing to be afraid of and everything is possible." 5.Overall 156.97 Alissa Czisny 5.FS 96.67 (40.22+58.45 -2). Czisny "tweaked" her left lower calf/ankle practicing a triple flip on Thursday. She explained, "It’s sore but it will be fine. It’s something I did in practice here but it certainly wasn’t easy to skate on. It happened at the very beginning of practice. It was just the way I picked on a flip. It's one of those things that can happen. There's not much you can do."U.S. Figure Skating team doctors Peter Breen and Jen Burke examined the injury and said competing would not cause further damage. Czisny appeared to take the situation calmly. "It’s still early in the season. I’m going to go home, take a little time (a week or so) and rest." Coach, Jason Dungjen, put a positive light on the matter. "Actually, if it had to happen, this is the perfect time. I’m going to Italian nationals (with Valentina Marchei) so I won’t be at the rink (Detroit FSC). When I get back, it still gives us five weeks until U.S. nationals." This was Czisny’s third appearance in the Final. She finished sixth in 2006 but won gold last year. Back in 2003, she was 5th in the Junior Grand Prix Final. In her Free, set to Valse Triste (Sad Waltz which seemed very appropriate in view of the unfortunate performance), the 2009 and current national champion, wore a royal blue sleeveless creation. Blue for a blue day! She had the sort of day only a fellow US international competitor like Rachael Flatt could truly appreciate. Flatt bombed in this season’s Skate Canada Grand Prix in Mississauga in October, earning only 73.99 points for her Free (22.68 lower than Czisny’s FS point total here in Quebec). The 24-year-old Czisny, who was only 10th in nationals when Flatt dethroned her and won the 2010 US title, just appeared to have no power. But, even when she falls, Czisny is worth watching because of her matchless spins, spirals and sheer grace. She received a single arrow for both triple Lutzes, for her second triple Loop and for her first double Axel on which she fell. She also fell on her second double Axel which was not given an arrow. A single arrow indicates that the jump’s rotation was not fully achieved, but the problem was not serious enough for the Technical Panel to give two arrows, which means the jump is downgraded (generally from a triple to a double). Of her 12 required elements, Czisny received positive GoEs for only five, - the choreographed spirals which were awarded unanimous +2s by the nine-member judging panel; her three spins, which were all awarded the maximum Level 4 with the flying camel earning three +3s, the maximum GoE; the change foot combination getting one vote of +3; and her final move, the matchless layback spin getting unanimous +3s. That went a long way to helping the audience forget and forgive what had assailed their eyes in the previous four minutes. Czisny earned Level 2 for her circular steps which came immediately before her mesmerizing spinning finish. What can you say after such a disaster? "Obviously today was not my best and I’m disappointed in that. I learned to be tough and push through some pain." |
2011 Grand Prix Final
Ladies Medalists
|