Starting Order - Free Dance
Warmup Group 1
1. Rachel Tibbetts & Collin Brubaker, USA
2. Sarah Arnold & Justin Trojek, CAN
3. Stefanie Frohberg & Tim Giesen, GER
4. Alexandra Paul & Michell Islam, CAN
Warmup Group 2
5. Kristina Gorshkova & Vitali Butikov, RUS
6. Madison Chock & Greg Zuerlein, USA
7. Pernelle Carron & Lloyd Jones, FRA
8. Vanessa Crone & Paul Poirier, CAN
9. Sinead Kerr & John Kerr. GBR
Start Time: 12:35
|
Free Dance Placements
|
Place |
Couple |
Country |
1 |
Vanessa Crone & Paul Poirier
|
CAN
|
2 |
Alexandra Paul & Michell Islam
|
CAN
|
3 |
Sinead Kerr & John Kerr
|
GBR
|
4 |
Madison Chock & Greg Zuerlein |
USA |
5 |
Pernelle Carron & Lloyd Jones
|
FRA
|
6 |
Kristina Gorshkova & Vitali Butikov
|
RUS
|
7 |
Sarah Arnold & Justin Trojek
|
CAN
|
8 |
Stefanie Frohberg & Tim Giesen
|
GER
|
9 |
Rachel Tibbetts & Collin Brubaker
|
USA
|
|
Crone
& Poirier channel Chris Dean; Win first Grand Prix gold
Brilliant
Senior Debut by Paul & Islam; Second in Free
Chock & Zuerlein Win Their First GP Medal With Two Fourth Places 1.Total
Score 154.42; 1.FD 91.47 (45.74+45.73) Vanessa CRONE & Paul POIRIER
presented their difficult Free Dance set to Eleanor Rigby by
John Lennon and Paul McCartney, performed by Joshua Bell, choreographed by
Christopher Dean, to
almost universal applause. Their emergence is the one good thing to come
out of Virtue & Moir’s withdrawal due to her calf surgery.
Crone & Poirier’s coach, Carol Lane
(née Long), who trains them in Scarborough, knew Dean (the 1984 gold and
1994 bronze Olympic medalist) from her competitive days in Britain. She
persuaded him to come to Toronto for a week to produce this routine. She
explained, "I thought it would be a good fit. I told Chris that he
would enjoy working with them because anything he could dream up, they
were going to be able to do it."
Although they were seventh in only their
second Worlds last March, Crone & Poirier were less pleased with their
Olympic result, where they finished 14th, two places down from
their debut in Worlds in 2009. Lane said, "At this stage, Vanessa and
Paul need to stretch themselves to the limit. We ventured out to Chris
because we wanted that to happen. He is known for devising very difficult
choreography and this was the time for them to be challenged to their
limit."
Poirier said, "It turned out to be a
really magical week. He threw some big challenges our way, particularly in
footwork and transitional movements. R esults
are definitely always on your mind, but, at that point, Vanessa and I were
focused on our performance, which we felt was quite good. Chris expanded
what we had. It was very difficult and it took a lot of time afterwards
for us to make the maximum of what he had given us and fully take
advantage of all the possibilities. To make it all come together was more
than just difficult. Vanessa and I are really proud of what we
accomplished and that we could show the full potential.
"After the national team training
camp, (in September) our coaches Carol and Juris (Razguliaevs), made us an
extremely detailed training program. We organized every hour of every day
with specific items about what we’d work on. We came in here with the
most confidence ever."
Crone, who is from Newmarket, Ontario and
turned 20 on the day of the Short Dance, and Poirier, who will be 19 on
November 6 and is from Unionville, Ontario, were a mere one-one-hundredths
of a point behind Sinead and John Kerr, who were performing under less
than ideal conditions, going into the Free. Crone was attired in a
straight-forward, long sleeved bright red dress which, while thrusting her
into the limelight, did not interfere with their lines. Poirier was in
royal blue. The Beatles era was one in which men began wearing more
flamboyant outfits and the staid "old" order was eclipsed,
resulting in changes around the world. The costumes were meant to reflect
that revolutionary trend, although, today, it is a very dated look. (The
Beatles were the first to make longish hair respectable for men.)
The young twosome began their four-minute
routine with a Level 4 combination spin which earned one +3. Six other
judges thought it worthy of +2 GoE and two misers gave only +1 producing a
combined GoE of +0.93 over the base value. Might the writer cynically put
forward the possibility that the +3 was punched in by the Canadian judge
Elizabeth Clark? That judge also gave a +3 (the maximum possible) for
Crone & Poirier’s serpentine and final rotational lifts which were
both judged Level 4 by the Technical Specialist, former Canadian ice
dancer, Rock LeMay, and former British champion (with wife Marika
Humphreys) Sergei Baranov, who were overseen by Controller Gilles
Vandenbroeck. For each of the other two lifts, the generous judge was
joined by one other (not the same) judge, who also punched in a +3.
Crone & Porier’s first lift, a
straight line, was only Level 2 with +0.64 GoE, leaving room for
advancement. The diagonal steps were lovely, earning Level 3. No couple
earned a Level 4 for this move for which the youngsters were rewarded with
four +2s and five +1s. Their twizzles were Level 3 with five votes for a
+2 GoE and four for +1. Their Level 3 Serpentine Steps earned +1.57 over
their base value of 6.50.
Looking at the detailed printout sheets,
two couples, Crone & Poirier and Carron & Jones, appear to do only
eight elements while the others do nine and the Russians 10. This freedom
has come about because the ISU is trying to help age variety. The Russians
do two "transition" lifts while the other couples presented only
one of these which do not get Levels and count only in helping get higher
component marks (or less if you mess it up). In addition, Crone &
Poirier chose to present a (two in one) "long" Serpentine lift
which has a Level 4 base value of 8 points and the French team did a
combined curve to rotational lift, each part of which has a base value for
Level 4 of 4points. The rest of the field chose to do four
"short" lifts with each having a Level 4 base value of 4 points.
Crone & Poirier’s whole performance
generated an extreme energy from the audience who were obviously enjoying
themselves, cheering for their home country competitors. That did not stop
them greeting the other competitors with very generous applause. The
compactness of this small arena, which is only a few years old, fostered a
great atmosphere with spectators very close to the ice. Crone &
Poirier’s overall winning margin was 4.82. This was their third Grand
Prix medal. They earned silver in the 2008 Skate Canada and bronze in the
2009 NHK in Nagano, Japan. Crone & Poirier’s next competitive
appearance is in Skate America November 12-14. "Obviously our goal is
to get into the Grand Prix Final again," Crone said. They finished
sixth in last season’s Final.
2.Total
149.80; FD 3. 86.84 (39.36+47.61) Sinead and John KERR
skated to Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 3: Redemption. Skating
last, immediately after the Canadian winners, Sinead, 31, and John Kerr,
30, might have proved anti-climactic had the audience not been so generous
with their applause. The concept of the Scottish sister and brother’s
new Free Dance is "a return to the innocence of childhood". Her
opening stance, covering her eyes with her hands as in a hide-and-seek
game is a novel approach. John then taps her hands and she
"awakes" to a past era when they were children, the world was
new, and they had no cares or responsibilities.
"This season, we are skating for
ourselves not for other people’s Olympic expectations," John
explained. "Peter Tchernyshev choreographed the routine and we’re
having fun with it." His sister added, "We expected to retire
last season but we didn’t achieve what we wanted so we’ve stayed
around. We know it will be hard to hold off the youngsters. They are
improving by the second. But we’re so much more relaxed now we are doing
it just for our own enjoyment, just like we did when we first came into
the sport, when we were children.
"Sinead and I have created a lot of
our own work during our career so it was nice to have someone else take
the reins. Even though we have always enjoyed choreographing, it was nice
to not have the pressure of having to come up with something new and
original. Peter was awesome to work with and it really gave us fresh
inspiration and impetus for the year ahead. This was something we had to
think long and hard about. Sinead and I have always felt that we should
leave the stage with the audience wanting more which is why we felt that
2010 might be a good time to call it quits. Let’s call this our extended
curtain call then."
They were operating with a handicap. On
October 5, a day before they were to fly to Helsinki to compete in the
Finlandia Cup, an event they won at the beginning of last season, Sinead
injured her right shoulder which meant she could not practice. "The
doctors told me if I did not rest and go through rehabilitation and
recuperation, I would have to have an operation like (Russian pair skater)
Yuko Kavaguti had in April. That side-lines you for a long time."
It was a double whammy. Not only were they
missing the necessary training for an event of this importance, they did
not have the opportunity of putting their routines in front of an
international panel and getting feed-back which is so necessary under this
new system in which changes and different interpretations are constantly
being made.
Lack of practice was obvious in their one
very noticeable error when she went to stand with her blades on his upper
thighs in their straight line lift after being in a high position, and the
blades slipped off. Fortunately he reacted in a split second and caught
her so that, although they were penalized with a negative GoE (-0.79),
they still accomplished enough positions to earn Level 4. They also were
rewarded with Level 4 for their other two lifts. "I’m not exactly
sure what happened," Sinead explained. "It’s a hard lift for
us. It’s a timing issue more than anything." John added, "We’re
doing a lot of elements we’ve never done before. We’ll go back (to New
Jersey) and re-evaluate."
3.Total
139.05; 4.FD 84.86 (44.27+40.59) Madison CHOCK & Greg ZUERLEIN’s
new Free is to Cabaret and it suits them. Although she has bags of
personality, he has come under fire for not being out-going enough. Their
opening allows him to act the role Joel Grey played in the movie, of a
greasy Master of Ceremonies in a seedy, decadent night club. She was in
black, with Peacock feathers in her dark hair, looking far too glamorous
for such a place of dubious entertainment.
Zuerlein explained, "I almost have the
lead role. It’s usually Maddie who is in front. I’m definitely playing
a very different character. Obviously, we’ve watched the movie. His
partner added that they have modified the roles, making their presentation
reflect more of their own personalities.
They received Level 4s for their opening
move, the twizzles (with +0.57 GoE), for all three lifts (with +0.93 for
the straight line; +0.71 for the curve; and +0.71 for the rotational) and
for their straight line steps (0.93). Chock had a slip during the one-foot
part of their second element, the circular steps, which brought them down
to a Level 2 but the move was still good enough for a +0.86 GoE.
"That was something that can be fixed," Chock said. Their
midline steps gained Level 3 and +0.71. Asked about their surprising Level
1 for a lift in the Short Dance, they both said they still did not
understand why that had happened because it had got Level 4s the previous
season. Chock ventured, "It may be something to do with repeating a
position at different heights."
The duo, who placed fifth in the US
championships in their first entry as Seniors last January, suffered a
shock at the Lake Placid championships this summer when officials
explained they did not like their Free Dance set to Nothing Else
Matters by Santa Esmeralda and Satellite by Santana Feat and
Jorge Moreno. "That was a setback, but we got over it," Chock
admitted. "And this routine is better. It’s more fun."
4.Total
138.16; 2.FD 87.61 (45.99+41.62) Alexandra PAUL &
Mitchell ISLAM caused a sensation with their delightful routine set
to As Time Goes By by Herman Hupfeld. The music, which was made
famous in the classic Humphrey Bogart movie Casablanca, also caused
a stir when Kurt Browning used a different version of it. Paul & Islam
were only sixth after the Short Dance, and so skated with the lower half.
The crowd gave them a standing ovation. William Thompson, Chief Executive
Officer of Skate Canada (the organization) said, "That was exquisite.
For such a young team just coming out of junior, it was brilliant. I’m
thrilled."
Paul, 19, and Islam, 20, who were the
silver medalists at Junior Worlds in Holland in March, were making their
Senior GP debut. They have the same ‘look’ as Virtue and Moir. She
said, "We’ve been told that a lot. We love watching them skate. We
are not deliberately trying to copy anything but we definitely want to
step up into their league and have the same great skating skills they
show. All the skaters do. I think maybe we’ve absorbed some aspects
subconsciously." They are still junior age eligible, but have decided
to move up to seniors. Islam said, "Like it is with a lot of sports
after the Olympics, a new chapter is being written in international figure
skating. We feel we’re definitely ready to make that plunge into the ‘big’
league."
Islam was a longtime partner of Joanna
Lenko, who was forced out of the sport in 2007 because of heart problems.
"It was a tough time," said Islam. "I questioned whether I
wanted to keep going in figure skating. I trained for almost a year on my
own. Then I found Alex. We had been skating at the same rink and with the
same coaches so our styles matched and we made quick progress." (He
was also a hockey player, who also reached triple-A level as a defense
player, before quitting after his bantam year.)
Their second place in the Free brought them
up to just less than a point (0.89) behind the bronze medalists. Five of
their levels were the maximum four and the other three gained three. Only
they, and the Russians, managed to get nothing less than Level 3. Their
weakest element was their Level 4 spin, which earned only the base value,
and their last element, the curve lift, was given "only" +0.71.
However, four of their other moves earned a full point over their
respective base values, and they got +1.14 for both their circular steps
and rotational lift. Their other Grand Prix assignment is the Cup of
Russia, November 19-21.
5.Total
136.03; 5.FD.81.60 (41.52+40.08) Pernelle CARRON & Lloyd
JONES, naturally, were disappointed at dropping from third but were
still pleased at what they had achieved in only their second Grand Prix
and only his second season as a senior. (In their first, in Paris last
year, they were ninth.) Their Free was to the Rolling Stones’ Paint
it Black and Angie. They were over eight and a half points
ahead of the Russians. Four of their elements earned Level 4 including
both parts of their long lift and the circular steps were Level 3.
However, their midline steps and final curve lift got only Level 2 and the
steps got a negative -0.14. They opened their routine with Level 4 a
stationary lift getting a full point over the base value of 4. This is a
move which was invented by Crone & Poirier.
6.Total
127.45; 6 FD.75.89 (41.85+34.04) Kristina GORSHKOVA &
Vitali BUTIKOV skated to classic Latin American music, a Cha Cha
by Santa Esmeralda and Luis Miguel’s Manana de Carneval. Their
coach Elena Tchaikovskaya was not at all pleased with her pupils’ marks.
"We did what the ISU told us they wanted – to go back to classic
ballroom dance. But they do not reward what they ask for." All but
three of their elements gained Level 4. The circular and diagonal steps
were Level 3 as was their curve lift.
7.Total
107.64; 7.FD.67.57 (36.08+31.49) Sarah ARNOLD Justin
TROJEK, were the replacements for Virtue & Moir, an assignment
earned by their showing in placing eighth in the Nebelhorn Trophy this
summer. They used four tracks from the soundtrack of the movie Amélie
(Poulain) by Yann Tiersen. (This was the first choice for Olympic
silver medalist Meryl Davis & Charlie White for their Short Dance, but
US officials told them it wasn’t powerful enough for them.)
Arnold explained, "Last year we skated
to Don’t Cry for Me Argentina. It showed off our power and
chemistry with one another. We tried to stay away from something romantic
this year and have a selection of music that made us rely on our skating,
not the music. We had Pasquale Camerlengo choreograph our free dance. We
felt that his style suited the music very well.
"Justin and I watched the movie and
loved it, but we couldn’t think of a way to portray the plot of the
movie on the ice. So we decided to make up our own story. For some reason
I felt that Pasquale’s choreography was so fluid that I felt like I was
the wind, and from there we decided Justin was going to be a tree."
That explains why he wears brown. Arnold continued, "It’s a story
of how the two elements of nature move together. When we have our costumes
on, we really feel like we’re in character." They finished
two-and-a- half points ahead of the Germans but almost ten points behind
the Russians, despite earning Level 4 for five of their eight required
elements. Their circular and diagonal steps were Level 2 and their final
lift only Level 1.
8.Total
105.10; 8 FD.62.10 (33.39+28.71) Stefanie FROHBERG & Tim
GIESEN from Berlin performed Flamenco, choreographed by the Bulgarian
world champions, Albena Denkova and Maxim Staviski. She wears a
knee-length black outfit with a pattern of flowers. The German junior
champions teamed up last year and were 11th in the World Junior
Championships this March, four places behind Tibbetts & Brubaker.
However, this time, they finished over nine points ahead of them, despite
earning no marks for their fourth element, the rotational lift.
9.Total
95.86; 9 FD.58.98 (33.10+27.88-2.0) Rachel TIBBETTS &
Collin BRUBAKER, the 2010 US Junior silver medalists, who were
seventh in the World Juniors in March, performed a routine choreographed
by Tom Dickson set to three pieces: Tango Para Percusion by Lalo
Schiffrin; Stan Getz’s classic, The Girl from Ipanema performed
by Manoelito Martins; and Dance of the Headhunters by Tito Puente,
dressed in black with red highlights.
They had an initiation by fire in this
their senior international debut. There was one bright point – the
winners received only Level 3 for their twizzles while Tibbetts and
Brubaker earned the maximum Level 4. But they were the only couple of the
nine teams from six countries to be saddled with deductions. They lost one
point for not completing a lift in the allocated time and another for his
fall. Brubaker said, "It wasn’t my fault. She kicked my foot. We
were a little late in the music and were forced to change our choreography
a bit, and her skate clashed with my blade. But this was definitely a good
experience and we have learned a lot." Hurting them even more than
those faults were the Level 1s, for their first rotational lift and for
their Midline steps.
|