2005

Skate America

Men's Event

By Alexandra Stevenson

 

 

All Photos Copyright 2005 by George S. Rossano

 
Final Standings
Place Skater Country SP FS
1 Daisuke Takahashi JPN 1 1
2 Evan Lysacek USA 3 3
3 Brian Joubert FRA 4 2
4 Kevin van der Perren BEL 2 4
5 Yannick Ponsero FRA 5 6
6 Timothy Goebel USA 6 8
7 Dennis Phan USA 7 7
8

Sergei Davydov

BLR 8 10
9

Christopher Mabee

CAN 11 5
10 Lun Song CHN 9 11
11 Kristoffer Berntsson SWE 10 12
12 Silvio Smalun GER 12 9

 

Short Program

 
Starting Order - Short Program
  1. Evan Lysacek

  2. Dennis Phan

  3. Kevin van der Perren

  4. Timothy Goebel

  5. Silvio Smalun

  6. Sergei Davydov

  7. Lun Song

  8. Brian Joubert

  9. Daisuke Takahashi

  10. Kristoffer Berntsson

  11. Christopher Mabee

  12. Yannick Ponsero

 

Short Program Placements
Place Skater Country
1 Daisuke Takahashi JPN
2 Kevin van der Perren BEL
3 Evan Lysacek USA
4 Brian Joubert FRA
5 Yannick Ponsero FRA
6 Timothy Goebel USA
7 Dennis Phan USA
8

Sergei Davydov

BLR
9 Lun Song CHN
10 Kristoffer Berntsson SWE
11

Christopher Mabee

CAN
12 Silvio Smalun GER


Daisuke Takahashi

"Surprised", is how Daisuke Takahashi described his feelings after discovering he was in the lead after the short program. When quizzed by a battery of journalists, the seemingly embarrassed 19 year old admitted, "Today’s performance was not bad, but not good. I’m surprised and happy."

He accomplished his triple flip to triple toe loop combination of jumps gaining a more than satisfactory +1 Grade of Execution (GOE). But he fell on his second move, the triple Axel. That meant he received the lowest possible GOE, -3, and a deduction of 1.0 for the fall. However, he still gained 4.50 points because he completed three full revolutions. All of his other moves got slight positive GOE’s including his triple Lutz. All three of his spins received Level 3 but both footwork sequences were only Level 2.

Kevin van der Perren, who lies second, gained a marginal 0.34 more for his element score but Takahashi, who performed to the soundtrack from Moulin Rouge, was rewarded with the top component scores. Takahashi is from Kurashiki, a historical town in Okayama Prefecture which is in the west of Japan. He is trained in the city of Okayama by Utako Nagamitsu.

Asked how he came to take up skating, Takahashi explained through an interpreter, "I was always crying and my parents became very worried about me. They decided I should take up sports to toughen me up. I wanted to skate so I started when I was eight."

He won the world junior championship in 2002. However, after winning the bronze in the Four Continents Championships earlier this year, he had a setback dropping four places in Moscow to 15th from his standing the previous year in his debut at worlds at senior level.

"Since then, I finished school. I have worked much harder (with his hopes fueled by the hopes of making the Olympic team) and I also have a new choreographer." And who would that be? Why Nikolai Morosov, of course.

Takahashi performed immediately following one of the favorites, Brian Joubert, who also wasn’t perfect and lies fourth. Evan Lysacek is third.

Van der Perren has kept his fun 2 minute 50 second routine to Computergame by Safri Duo. The 23 year old from Belgium wore a snazzy black and silver shiny outfit with Exit written in large silver letters on his back and a red bent arrow over his right shoulder. He also sports a diamond and a silver stud in this left ear plus two silver studs in his right eyebrow. On him, it looks effective.

Van der Perren first caught the attention of fans with a stunning combination of three triple jumps, which scores highly in the new system. Though he did not then have a quad, he beat others who did. A reverse situation occurred in Atlantic City where he began with a quad toe to triple toe. "I’m very happy to have landed my first quad ever in competition in the short program. Tomorrow, I hope it’s going to work again. I didn’t put the quad in before because I did not want to do that until my triple Axel was solid. I didn’t want to mess up two elements."

Although he also landed his triple Axel on Thursday, he lost his edge stumbling soon afterwards. The judges harshly gave him a -1.40 GOE, but his misstep was not classed as a fall and so he did not get a deduction. He said he would have to concentrate better in the future. "I must tell myself, ‘It’s not over after the first jump." He was so excited that the combination had gone well. "I only got the quad in August."

Van der Perren’s triple Lutz gained a slight positive GOE. BUT his only Level 3 was for his first spin, a flying sit. Though he received a Level 2 for his final move, a change foot combination spin, both his step sequences were only Level 1 as was his change foot sit spin. It was these low levels which kept him out of first place, which he lost by only 0.31. He is trained by Vera Vandecaveye in the Belgian cities of Leuven and Deurne. His choreographer is former American ice dancer, Diana Goolsbey.

Van der Perren has been Belgian champion since 2000 and has competed in the European and world championships for the past six years. "I didn’t really start skating till I was quite old. Skating is such an expensive sport. My parents said, ‘Go play soccer with your brother because professional players make good money.’ But I didn’t want to do that. A group of people now give me support and I train with only a few others on the ice. I get ice for four hours a day. When I was younger, I liked having others around to push me but now I’m fine. I don’t need others to spur me on."

When he was 19, Van der Perren won the silver at the 2002 at the junior world championships, becoming the first Belgian to medal in an ISU championship for 54 years. He was 12th in the Salt Lake Games and is looking forward to Turin in February. "I wasn’t nervous at those Olympics because I had to do so much to get there. The Belgian Olympic Association said I had to medal at a Grand Prix event and also come in the top 12 in Europe. I had to meet so many goals to get to Salt Lake so that when I did, I just relaxed and enjoyed myself.

He said he did about 50 quads a day "because your body has to get used to them." He later amended that statement. "I don’t count the number but I do lots." Isn’t that hard on his body? Van der Perren shrugged off the fear of injury. "I’m already injured. On my right side, I have a knee problem and on the left I have a heel problem and I also have back problems.

By placing eighth in the last worlds, Van der Perren qualified his country to send two men to the upcoming Olympics. Unfortunately, his tiny country does not have a suitable second entry much to the joy of the man who finished seventh in Vienna last week. There were initially only six spots left on the Olympic team which were decided on the results of the Karl Schaefer Memorial competition. When the head of the Belgian Association gave back their unneeded second spot, Zoltan Toth of Hungary, got his chance for the Olympics.

Lysacek¸ who skated first of the 12 men from nine countries, performed to Vamos a Bailar by the Gypsy Kings in a red blousy V-necked top trimmed in silver and black pants. He put a lot of effort into the program but looked relieved at the end at having completed his eight elements. "Was I relieved? I suppose so. My warm-up wasn’t very good. I definitely wanted to stay on my feet and I did that but no, I don’t think the showing was enough to win the short." His score was only 1.35 behind first place.

"Today is the first time I’ve performed that short so I’m still learning. I think for this time out I felt pretty comfortable with it. My plan is not to be perfect at the beginning of the season, so hopefully things will keep improving and it will get better and better. I’m not anywhere near my peak. I want my peak form at nationals. My main focus now is staying healthy.

"I’m reading the book, What to Say When You Talk to Yourself, and it’s about positive affirmation. One of the stories in the book is about this person who had never bowled before. He wrote on his hand, ‘I bowl strikes.’ And just said it over and over and over again and he bowled a perfect game. So I wrote on my hand, ‘I skate clean programs’ and just kept saying it today and I think it helped me stand up on the triple Axel."

That sort of positive affirmation is more generally accepted on a visual level. Most coaches have their pupils mentally picture themselves going through a perfect program either while playing the music, or imagining the accompaniment.

However, the hand note obviously worked for Lysacek, who won the silver medal in the world junior championships a disappointing three times. In Atlantic City, his opening move, the triple Axel, was landed with the weight a little too forward and only held with a great deal of determination and muscle power, which resulted in a -1 GOE. His other elements, including the triple Lutz to triple toe loop and triple flip from footwork, were all accomplished well. Two of his three spins were Level 3 and the other a Level 2.

The 20 year old world championship bronze medalist, who is trained by Frank Carroll and Ken Congemi in El Segundo, CA, had a shaky outing two weeks ago at the Campbells Invitational event. He finished sixth in a field of six there after two footing his opening jump, the quad toe, and falling twice in St. Paul in the free skating only event. Paul.

"I feel a lot more pressure, even from myself, to succeed this year and surpass the results that I had from last year. I’ve been working hard but actually I’ve been getting a little bit nervous the last two competitions. I rose quickly to the elite group of skaters. It’s tough to stay up there and everyone kind of wants to knock you down. I didn’t deal with that last year because I had nothing to loose then."

Asked to evaluate his pupil, Carroll said, "It’s very hard for me to look at one of my own skaters. The triple Axel was not landed as well as he could but he had good energy. I’d like to see him do a quad in the short. He’s a little better than last year. He’s improving with time. He needs to learn to chill out and go for it. He’s got to get on the ice looking like a tiger. Figure skating is a big head game. He has to think, ‘I am the killer.’ He can do that when he feels totally confident.

"Now competition is more math than it is skating. Lots of aspects have been made better but you lose a little of the musicality. You are required to do all your turns in the first 30 percent of your foot work, but maybe the music doesn’t call for that. The girls are all doing the same spiral sequence in the short and the long because they’ve learned what gets the most points. That is less interesting for the public. And there are still some very strange values. For instance, an inside Axel is not given any value but a half loop is considered a jump. And it’s impossible to fully make sure the system is fair. Human beings are still pushing the pluses and minuses. There’s always going to be some error if humans are doing it."

Joubert, who was runner-up for the world title in 2004, was a substantial 6.22 points behind the leader. The Frenchman put his hand down on the quad toe loop and so was only able to get airborne for a double toe, and his triple Axel was low. Both moves got a -2.0 GOE. Then, in his Level 1 straight line step sequence, he fell.

Tim Goebel, skating to Sing, Sing, Sing in a blue sparkly top with black suspenders, untied tie, and black pants had a problem singling his triple Axel in the warm-up but managed this feat in the routine which began badly when he fell on his quad Salchow attempt which was downgraded to a triple. He lies sixth behind the second French entry, Yannick Ponsero who was last to skate.

Dennis Phan, a 20 year old, from Riverside, CA, who is trained by Tammy Gambill, lies seventh only one place but a large 4.80 points behind former US champion, Tim Goebel, who is sixth.

 

Free Skating

 
Starting Order - Free Skating
  1. Kristoffer Berntsson

  2. Dennis Phan

  3. Silvio Smalun

  4. Lun Song

  5. Christopher Mabee

  6. Sergei Davydov

  7. Evan Lysacek

  8. Timothy Goebel

  9. Kevin van der Perren

  10. Daisuke Takahashi

  11. Yannick Ponsero

  12. Brian Joubert

 

Free Skating Placements
Place Skater Country
1 Daisuke Takahashi JPN
2 Brian Joubert FRA
3 Evan Lysacek USA
4 Kevin van der Perren BEL
5

Christopher Mabee

CAN
6 Yannick Ponsero FRA
7 Dennis Phan USA
8 Timothy Goebel USA
9 Silvio Smalun GER
10

Sergei Davydov

BLR
11 Lun Song CHN
12 Kristoffer Berntsson SWE


Evan Lysacek

 


Friday night belonged to Takahashi. Performing his four and a half minute routine to Rachmaninov’s stirring, emotional, romantic Piano Concerto #2, he flowed through his moves with sureness and grace. His only error was a two footed landing on his first jump, the quad toe, for which he received a -2 GOE. His second move was a triple Axel to triple toe which gained a +1. And his triple Lutz to triple toe also had a positive GOE. He did, however, reduce his second Axel jump to a double.

A look of utter joy filled his face as he pumped his fists into the air at the end. "This was my first Grand Prix win. This is a big competition and winning gave me confidence for this season. I would like to keep this standard up."

But he did not rank the performance as best ever. "The best was Junior Worlds. This was maybe, second or third." He was more surprised at his win here "because I’m a senior, now. I just wanted to skate well here. I didn’t care about the results." He finished an amazing 24.83 points ahead of Lysacek.

He has used classical music in the past and likes this music, which Lysacek has also skated to. "But I wanted to try something different this season. At the very beginning I hesitated to skate to classical again. But then I started to love this music."

Lysacek, who skated immediately following the second warm-up, finished with the silver although he was third in both short and long. He skated to Grease so very much better than when he debuted the piece in St. Paul. The story of this very successful musical is somewhat old-fashioned by today’s standards. A group of teenagers with altogether far too much energy find love over a summer.

"The music was a huge decision," Lysacek said. He plays the main character, Danny Zuko a little too politely. But no doubt he’ll get into shaking his hips a bit more as his interpretation of the swaggering heartthrob develops as the season progresses.

He loves the vibrancy and energy in the music but he’s not enamored with slobbering his hair with grease and hair spray. "I can’t wait to wash my hair. I must have set the fight against global warming back years with all the hair spray I had to use. But it’s a fun program. Since last year’s Singing in the Rain, I’ve got boxes of mail from people telling me they love seeing something which uses music they can recognize and which makes them feel good. They say they love the smiling. I know it’s a sport and it’s technical but I think a more upbeat approach can bring more people back to watching skating."

When his team was deciding which music to do, they ran into someone in a music studio who had played bass guitar in the orchestra pit of the stage production of Grease for six years. They took that to be a sign.

His outfit is a complete change from St. Paul. "The leather was heavy and the denim hot." This time though he’s all in black it’s more of a summer look with a short sleeved shirt with a couple of silver lines indicating zips.

This time he wrote on his hand, ‘Attack!’ He began with a good triple Lutz to triple toe loop and although he got a slight minus (-0.40 GOE) for his triple Axel to double toe he stayed on his feet on both that and the second triple Axel which also received a small negative of -0.80 taken off from the base value.

There were two items in which he reduced the difficulty. His three jump combination became double (instead of triple) flip to double toe to double loop and he singled his second Lutz.

"Those two mistakes I made tonight were mental errors. I lost my concentration for a second, but overall I think I stayed with the program and stayed in character. I tried to perform the best for the audience, to control the expression, and I think they are appreciative. Definitely the quad is going to go in. I did some good ones this weekend in practice, but this is the beginning of the season and I have steps in the ladder to reach and that’s going to be the next one."

Joubert skated last. The three time French champion was second in the long but third overall, 3.43 points behind Lysacek, because of his fourth place in the short which he performed to the soundtrack from the soundtrack of the James Bond movie, Die Another Day. For the long, he used the Irish music, Lord of the Dance. That was despite his being the only competitor to get a Level 4 in the short, which was for his change foot combination spin. He did not receive a Level 4, however, in the long.

"Last season the music was a mistake. It was too slow. I wanted faster music. I used this music before for an exhibition," said the 21 year old from Poitiers, which is a little way to the west of Paris. "I’m a little disappointed because I did not do a clean program. My practices at home and were here very good."

The former European champion, who has a new coach this season, Russian, Andrei Berezintsev, fell on his first move, a quad toe which was meant to be a combination. The following triple Axel and triple Lutz were good. "After I missed the combination, I was thinking how I could add a jump." The men are only allowed eight jumping passes. Joubert decided to add a double toe to his first triple flip, but that messed up his concentration and he doubled instead of tripled the following jump, his second Axel. That was also supposed to be a combination but he wasn’t able to bring it off. He put a hand down on the triple loop which result in -2 GOE but quickly followed with good triple Salchow and flip jumps which were given an extra 10% for being later in the routine.

There was a great deal of pressure on Joubert for this last season. He had placed second to Evgeny Plushenko for the world title in 2004 but earlier this year, after the titleholder pulled out of worlds, Joubert was not able to take advantage of that opportunity. Instead, he dropped to sixth overall, the same place he’d gained in his second appearance in that event in 2003.

Were any of the medalists going out gambling in this city full of casinos? "Oh, no," said Lysacek. "I’m too young." Takahashi isn’t giving in to temptation either. "I’m afraid I’d get addicted." But Joubert is game. "Maybe with some other skaters, I will go and have some fun."

Van der Perren dropped from second to fourth overall, a significant 5.11 points behind Joubert. Skating to Pirates of the Carribean, Van der Perren got off to a bad start, singling his planned quad toe, a jump he had done for the first time in the short the previous day. He recovered to bring off a triple Axel to triple toe and followed with the three jump combination for which he is famous, triple flip-triple toe-triple loop which has a base value of 14.5, and he received a slight positive GOE which added 0.3 to that score.

He singled his planned second triple Axel. "I was tired. That always seems to happen to me in the free. It’s the beginning of the season so it’s not so bad. I’ll just have to wait out the season and see if it can get better. I would have liked to attempt a second quad but I couldn’t figure out a place to do it."

Joubert’s teammate, Yannick Ponsero, the silver medal winner from the last world junior championships who turned 19 on October 17, held onto fifth place although he was only sixth in the long performing to a French version of the Irish music, The Lakes of Conemara.

In fifth place in the long but pulling up only two places to finish ninth overall was the 20 year old Christopher Mabee from Tillsonburg, Ontario, who is trained by Doug Leigh.

In the short he had fallen three times not only getting -3 GOEs but incurring a penalty of -3.0 for the three deductions. Leigh said at that time, "That was well below his average skate. It was out of character but it is his first senior international. He’s in with the big guys."

The personable Mabee, who was fifth in the last Canadian senior championships, admitted, "Missing triple flips is not normal for me. Obviously it was not the skate I wanted. Maybe I was over analyzing too much. It was an off night. I’m going into the long with nothing to lose. I’ve got to prove myself even more tomorrow."

And he did. He took the ice skating fifth of the lower six competitors in regular brown trousers, a black shirt rolled up to the elbows and suspenders. His Big Band routine has great potential with several crowd pleasing miming moments. He doubled his first move meant to be a triple loop and singled his triple Axel, but he stayed on his feet and later tripled a toe loop combined with a triple Lutz. He finished with a smile and gained a great response from the crowd. He and Goebel were the only skaters to get a Level 4 in the long. Mabee received this accolade for his first spin, a sit.

Despite Goebel’s Level 4 flying sit spin, he was only eighth in the long. However, he held on to sixth place overall. "Honestly, I’ve really never popped that many jumps," he admitted. He began his Night on a Bald Mountain free with his ‘warm-up jump’, a triple flip but then fell on his quad Salchow which was deemed a triple. Then he singled an Axel which was planned as a combination and followed it with a double Axel. He did a triple Salchow but singled a loop. After his Level 3 flying combination spin he singled a Lutz. His change foot sit spin was Level 3 and just before he ended with a Level 2 change foot combination spin, he presented a good triple flip to toe loop. Both his footwork sequences were lower than expected. The circle was a Level 2 and the straight line a Level 1.

"I just don’t know what happened," said the former US champion, with an expression which resembled a deer caught in a hunter’s headlights.

Phan finished seventh in both sections and overall, 2.78 points behind Goebel. Skating his long to the soundtrack to National Treasure, he fell on his opening triple Axel and also later on his double Axel. He brought off a good triple Lutz to triple toe but doubled his planned triple flip and singled a second attempt.

 

2005 Skate America Men's Medalists

 

Return to title page